Mom of Three
  • Daily Grind
  • Quilts, Crafts & Stuff
  • Links
  • Adoption
  • About

School District Controversy

9/25/2013

18 Comments

 
Recently controversy has befallen my community, specifically our school district.  Our school district decided to change the policies regarding visitors to the school, and this partially came about because holiday parties and lunch time had gotten out of control.  Previously, anyone was allowed to attend school parties and lunch was open for parents to come every day of the week.

School parties were completely out of control.  Hundreds and hundreds of parents, grandparents, etc. were attending the holiday parties (Halloween, Christmas and Valentine's Day).  So many visitors arrived (800-1000 at least) at about the same time that it was impossible to check them in, so visitors signed in and headed back to classrooms.  The doors were basically open to anyone.  The classrooms were filled with parents sitting around mostly talking to each other and maybe snapping a few photos of their kid while 1 or 2 assigned room parents ran the games.  Parents brought elaborate fruit skewers, snacks and treat bags as though it was a competition to be better than the next class.  Most of the food wasn't eaten by the students.  As a volunteer, I threw large amounts of food away after each party.  

I remember viewing the parties differently after the Newtown tragedy last December.  Our school Christmas party was about a week after the shooting, and as I walked through the school it was obvious that anyone off the street could just walk in to the school and do whatever they wanted.  There were probably close to 1000 visitors (in addition to around 900 students and staff) for that party.  Perhaps it wouldn't be a deranged shooter (though it's possible), but consider people in the midst of bitter divorces/custody battles, parents with drug/alcohol problems, unstable family members, angry parents etc.  The possibilities for some kind of dangerous situation is endless.  

The superintendent said there were even a few cases where some students had to be removed from their own parties because they had anxiety over the amount of people in the room.  Think about how sad that is, and imagine it was your child who couldn't participate in holiday festivities.  She also said after conducting a district survey, students felt the most unsafe on these days because of the amount of strangers in the building, and teachers were most unhappy - they could barely join in the classroom celebration because of the amount of visitors.  I attended the parties because my kids asked me to since 'all the other Moms come'.  They were not fun.  

The days lunch visitors could come was also limited (to three days a week instead of five) just to lessen the number of visitors on campus for safety reasons.  More visitors means more monitors where the visitors are, which means education professionals had to put their work on hold to monitor for safety.  Imagine telling a doctor or lawyer they would have to stop working for an hour once a week to monitor visitors in their building.  Sounds absurd, doesn't it?  Having many visitors roaming around a campus can be stressful for everyone, including the staff.  Teachers attend many trainings on what to do in emergency situations, including what to do when unidentified or un-badged visitors are roaming around.  Monitoring for extra visitors campus takes attention away from the main objective of schools - educating children.

So, of course, there are many parents who are very upset by this, and then a local news station did a story that sounded as though the district is telling parents they can't come to the school any more.  First of all, that is incorrect.  The facts are that parties will be limited to a maximum of three room-parents who are there to lead the party and games.  Treats are limited to a snack and drink and treat bags are not allowed.  It's back to the basics which means to let the kids relax and enjoy not doing any school work for one hour.  Parents are VERY WELCOME to come and volunteer at any time during the year.  Some of the volunteer opportunities that were sent home are: library, school festival (needs 100's of people for help), classroom assistance, reading, car line, box tops, and the list goes on.  

Many parents had comments following the news story.  Parents felt they have a right, no matter what, to come to the school any time they want, and damnit, no one better tell them any different.  They are tax payers after all.  Many said they would pull their kids from the district and feel the school is trying to assert control and push parents away so they can indoctrinate their kids (yes, this was actually said on a facebook thread).  Many parents said the 45 minute parties were a special time with their kid they just didn't want to miss.    

I am appalled.  It is unbelievably selfish for parents to think they can come in to a school at any time just because they want to.  Are the parties for the kids or the parents?  And why do parents feel entitled to do whatever they want?  It is not your right to just do whatever you want because you want to because your kid goes to school somewhere.  There are guidelines that need to be followed like most situations in life.

What about the right of every kid and teacher in the school to feel safe.  It is the right of the school to turn anyone away for any reason, although that is very unlikely to happen in most cases.  In the wake of Newtown and other tragedies we rely on our school to do everything in their power to keep our kids safe.  Well, in the end, that means that everyone has to follow the rules and no one is any more special than any other parent or adult in the school, no matter what your situation.  Everyone wants the best for their kid, but it still requires a collective effort.  Remember that every parent in a school is a stranger to probably at least 95% of the people in the school.

Some parents said they don't trust the teachers, and parents need to be in there monitoring what's going on.  First of all, parties are not the time to monitor your teacher's professional abilities as an educator.  Secondly, hovering over teachers because you don't trust them for some reason only undermines the role of the teacher in a classroom.  If you have a legitimate concern, there are pathways in which you can address the concern such as meeting with the teacher, meeting with the principal or removing your child from the situation.  You are always welcome to attend private schools or homeschool if you truly feel the school is doing a terrible job.  That is certainly within your rights. 

It is time that we collectively look at the good of the whole over the good of the individual.  The policies create safer environments for our kids, with a side effect of parties that are fun for the kids and serve as a bonding time among the members of a classroom, including the teacher.  Parties are not bonding time for parents and their children.  Parties are not a time for parents to visit with each other.  There are many ways parents can achieve those objectives such as family dinner time, reading together, helping with homework, weekend activities, playing boardgames, setting up playdates with other families.  Message me if you need more suggestions on how to have quality time with your children outside of school.  

It is our jobs as parents to raise functional adults, or rather, to 'parent ourselves out of a job' as I heard in a parenting class once.  If we are eating lunch with them and hovering over them at every chance that they have to explore independence, we are hurting them.  We are preventing them from having the tools to make decisions on their own, solve problems on their own and feel confident in situations away from Mom and Dad.  We want to let our kids know we trust them and that they are individuals capable of making decisions and solving problems on their own (if not, we need to give them the chance to fall down and learn from it) so that they may grow into successful adults.

I know I'm in the minority in supporting the school district on this decision.  I feel that parents are being selfish, and are foregoing the good of everyone for their own personal wants.  If our society is filled with people who feel entitled to do what they want and feel they are the exception to the rule we will be raising a generation of untrusting, self-righteous, entitled adults, and I will truly be worried for what will happen to our society.  

Everyone needs to refocus on what is really important - the safety and education of our children - which means everyone will have to follow rules that were well thought out, very justified (the superintendent explained the reasoning behind the decisions in depth at a PTO meeting) and in the best interest of those we care about the most - our children.  

All it takes is one tragedy to turn a community upside down.  Had the school district not changed the policy and something happened, what would the community be saying then?

18 Comments
You go girl!!!
9/25/2013 10:39:03 am

Reply
So true!
9/25/2013 11:25:28 am

Reply
Deborah Johansen
9/25/2013 12:26:17 pm

I love this, Mom of Three! I'm a former teacher in your district. I agree with every word you wrote. Thanks for speaking with common sense!

Reply
Mom of 2
9/25/2013 12:30:33 pm

I am one of the moms who had to get my kid early because of anxiety. Although i had concluded that the other kids were having fun and for this day, we could have mommy daughter time, no big deal.... It was the time I watched as divocring parents of a little girl both come as well as all of the grandparents. The grandparents get into a fight in the hallway to the point that the police had to get involved. That day not only did I see fear and anxiety in my daughter but shame in the other girls poor eyes... That day i realized the parties were for the moms and not the kids..

Reply
Another mom of three
9/25/2013 12:36:47 pm

Extremely well articulated and right on, but I don't think you're in the minority. I just think the majority is louder.

Reply
Another mom of three
9/25/2013 12:39:24 pm

Pardon me: the "perceived" majority is what I should have said.

Reply
I completely agree as well...you are not alone!
9/25/2013 01:03:26 pm

Reply
Tina
9/25/2013 01:53:04 pm

we were forced to move to another area... to a school where lunchtime and parties are VERY different. It caused ME anxiety at first (aren't we all missing out!?) but now I am enjoying it- the pressure is off, the parties are still fun (ok my kids DO miss the crazy over-the-top food and goodie bags) but they still have fun. For me- the pressure is OFF. No more wishing I had $1000 to shell out for a personal parking space, no more parking on a highway and hiking 200 yards (Windsong) and no more stressing to get there early... invariably on a day that we are all cramming in more than a full days worth of stuff anyway (last minute for Halloween, Christmas, and even sometimes Valentine's!) I am enjoying the stress free days and stress free parties... even if the candy doesn't last a MONTH OR TWO afterwards!! :) Chill moms... it will all be ok.

Reply
Teacher
9/25/2013 09:51:00 pm

You hit the nail on the head! I'm looking forwarded to a stress free party where my students and I can actually interact and have space to enjoy the party.

Reply
Empty Nester
9/25/2013 10:28:13 pm

Could not agree more! My children went through FISD and the parties were so over the top even back then. I remember feeling disgusted at the amount if food that was thrown away, not to mention the competition between moms and classes to out do each other. It was never really about the kids.

Reply
Teacher
9/25/2013 10:28:29 pm

Well said!!!
My first yr in this district was so eye opening. I had worked in other districts where I brought the treats and a movie and that was the party. The parties in this district were never fun, really? grandparents, aunts, uncles at a Halloween party. The waste of food and other stuff was unbelievable. Glad the district came up with this policy.

Reply
Another Mom
9/26/2013 01:15:46 am

Well said, you are spot on! I felt relief when I read the letter (which came out in May, why is everyone waiting until September to argue?) I am embarassed that parents are joining together to "propose" their ideas, and even more for bringing the media out in front of our children. I hope that FISD understands how many parents support them in this decision!

Reply
Mommy of 2
9/26/2013 01:46:00 am

Amen!!!! You said exactly what I've been thinking all along!!!

Reply
Barbara link
9/26/2013 07:16:35 am

Just down the road in Pasadena ISD, parents are only invited for lunch on Mondays. In CCISD, volunteers are screened with a background check and fingerprints. Party days were stopped all together years ago in many districts. I think we still have it pretty good in our district. Thank you for helping spread the word that it's not that the schools don't want to partner with you in your child's education, it's that safety has to be their first priority.

Reply
Ccisd mom
9/26/2013 08:06:37 am

We are not screened and fingerprinted in ccisd but we do have to fill out an online form every year to be a volunteer at school or for the field trips. They do scan your drivers license when you come into the office and check you into the school though.

Reply
Disagree
9/26/2013 07:49:22 am

If safety is truly an issue we need to implement real safety measures! The parties were completely out of control, but discussion and real security measures are helpful. Just because I am now excluded from a party or can't go to lunch on a Monday or Tuesday does not make my child any safer.
The doors in Newton were similar to the ones at Cline...the kind that visitors had to be buzzed in. It did not stop the maniac there.
Scaling back is not the same issue as safety and scaling back is not even the issue for me. Great let's scale back it seems a good idea for everyone involved. But that does not provide safety!

Reply
another mom of 3
9/26/2013 10:11:47 am

Amen. Great description and explanation..entitlement unfortunately has become a given in this town.

Reply
Very well said I think most parents in this town feel like they can do whatever they want and the rules don't apply to them. How parents can be so focused on social time for them than the safety of the whole school is ridiculous but does not surprise me.
9/26/2013 11:31:28 am

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Mom of Three

    Be sure to 'like' momofthree.com on Facebook!

    Top Mommy Blogs - Visit Top Mommy Blogs to vote for my blog

    Blog Submission Blog Sites
    Promote Blog
    Blog Community & Blog Directory
    Blogs Blog Gadgets Alessandra

    'Like' Mom of Three on Facebook for updates and fun stuff!

    Archives

    September 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Aging
    Airplane Travel With Kids
    Asthma
    Asthma Attack
    Backsplash
    Bathtime
    Best Cutout Cookies83eb656a51
    Best Sugar Cookies
    Birds
    Boys Will Be Boys
    Candy
    Christmas
    Christmas Cards
    Christmas Decorating
    Christmas Elf
    Christmas Elf Ideas
    Crawling
    Daylight Savings Time
    Elf On The Shelf
    Elf On The Shelf Ideas
    Family
    Family Plane Travel
    Fever
    Flying With Three Kids
    Garage Sales
    Gardening
    Ge Advantium Oven
    Gifts
    Hair
    Halloween
    Holiday
    Holiday Decorating
    Holidays
    Homemade Bird Feed
    Intro
    Janet Evanovich
    Jillian Michaels Body Revolution
    Kitchen Remodel
    Lamb Chops
    Make Your Own Soap
    Md Anderson
    Mealtime
    Mosquitoes
    Nebraska
    Nutrisystem
    One For The Money
    Organization
    Parenthood
    Perfect Pancakes
    Queen Creek Olive Mill
    Reactive Airway Disease
    Remodel
    School
    Seinfeld
    Sewing
    Sick
    Sick Babies
    Sleep
    Splitface Limestone
    Splitface Mosaic
    Squirrel Feeders
    Stephanie Plum
    Steroids For Children
    Stone Mural
    Stovetop Backsplash
    Sugar Cookie Recipe
    Teaching
    Texas
    Thanksgiving
    Three Kids
    Three Kids In The Bath
    Up All Night
    Vanilla Olive Oil
    Weight Loss

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.